Hello dear
Welcome to More Ice Cream
At More Ice Cream, we believe in the joy of delightful frozen treats crafted with love and nostalgia. Established in 2014 by Jim Kehoe in Middletown, MD, this charming ice cream parlor resides in a historic 1848 Lutheran parish house. Our inviting atmosphere features a relaxing wrap-around porch and a plethora of seating options, making it perfect for families and friends alike. With a tantalizing selection of flavors—from classic banana pudding cream to innovative brownie sundaes—there's something for everyone. As you savor our rich, creamy ice creams, you're not just enjoying a treat; you're part of a story that blends history with heartfelt community spirit.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Parfaits
Brownie Sundae
Black Knight
Banana Creme Pie
About
More Ice Cream
Welcome to the delightful world of More Ice Cream, a charming ice cream parlor nestled at 13 W Main St, Middletown, MD 21769. If you're on the hunt for the ultimate sweet treat, this gem is definitely worth a visit. Founded in 2014 by Jim Kehoe, More Ice Cream occupies a historic building that dates back to 1848, adding a unique touch to your ice cream experience.
As you step inside, you will be greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere, complete with nostalgic photos that celebrate the local heritage. The friendly staff is ready to help you navigate through a tempting selection of flavors from Garber’s 1912 Ice Cream. Whether you're craving rich butter pecan or indulgent banana pudding cream, you'll be thrilled with the array of choices available, including:
- Cones or Bowls: Choose a flavor and enjoy for only $3.77.
- Sundaes: Top it off with your favorite like hot fudge or caramel for just $3.75.
- Brownie Sundae: A double indulgence for $6.00.
- Parfaits: Unique options like Black Knight featuring triple chocolate bliss at $5.75.
- Milkshakes: Creamy goodness for only $5.50.
What truly stands out is the intimate setting that allows families and friends to gather and enjoy the simple pleasure of ice cream. Many visitors rave about the ample seating options that include a lovely wrap-around porch, making it a perfect spot to relish your scoop while soaking up the atmosphere. Not to mention, it’s a memory-making opportunity, as generations of families come together to share their favorite flavors—the peanut butter banana The King or the sweetly nostalgic S'mores.
However, if you're planning a visit, it’s wise to check operating hours as they can vary. Customers have noted how busy it can get, particularly during the summer months, so arrive prepared to possibly wait a bit for your delicious treat. But don’t let that deter you! The experience of enjoying high-quality ice cream in a historic locale, along with the attentive service, is well worth it.
In conclusion, More Ice Cream is not just an ice cream shop; it’s a delightful experience that invites you to indulge, reminisce, and create new memories. Whether you’re a local or passing through with loved ones, make sure to stop by for a scoop—you'll leave wanting more!
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Delicious ice cream with a great selection of offers! Can be pretty busy so be prepared to wait a little to be served if visiting during summer hours. Tons of seating options though parking is a bit limited. ”
“ UPDATE I found out there are multiple places that advertise Moores Ice Cream. If you go to the actual website it does say closed until April. Best ice cream hands down!! We drive an hour round trip to get their ice cream. The owner and staff are very pleasant and eager to help!! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!!! We come to More Ice Cream quite often. We rely on your website for ACCURATE information. We do not live locally, so it is a planned trip. Your website states for winter hours you are only closed Monday. Made a trip over only to find out you are only open Friday, Saturday, Sunday. Made a trip over on a Sunday around 3pm and you were closed. However, your website said you were open. Today, we once again checked your website. OPEN. We get there, and we find a small piece of paper taped to the window, closed today. You are our favorite ice cream place. Yet your business and website is proving to be unreliable. ”
“ June 28, 2024 Middletown has a great ICE CREAM parlor along the Old National Pike, called More Ice Cream! My wife and I lived across the mountain years ago in Keedysville, Middletown is halfway , on our routine trips into Frederick. Usually wed stop for gas, or building supplies, or lunch at the Main Cup. . . so were thrilled for this Ice Cream parlor. 1st time for us stopping in with our Grandkids for dessert, at Mores. Opened in 2014 by Jim Kehoe. Originally this spot was a Lutheran Parish house, built in 1848. Thank you Jim . . . for incorporating the original structure of the home ! As a former American History teacher, I love the nostalgic photos of Middletowns high school heroes up on the walls of your ice cream shop! Of course , the many flavors of Garbers 1912 Ice Cream are wonderful! Our group included 3 generations , no problem selecting our favorite flavors of ice cream! Your high school staff were helpful professionals! Our daughter from rival Urbana high school remembered her field hockey games against Middletown girls , a tough rivalry! Then out to the big wrap around porch to enjoy our desserts! Our little 2 4 year old Grandkids liked playing in the side yard. Felt safe away from the Main street traffic. Thank you ! Well certainly stop in again for More Ice Cream , on our way into Middletown, MD Ice Cream Licks Did you know . . . . . ? More Ice Cream is on Oldest U.S. road, National Pike , constructed 1811 1834 Scholars suggest frozen treats traced to 550 BCE to Persians sharbat, Gelato Marco Polos travels to Asia , 13th century, Discovered milk ice from Kublai Khan 1700 Maryland Royal Gov. served ice cream George Washington Tom Jefferson would have ice cream at their homes Jefferson 1st President to serve ice cream 1846 Nancy Johnson invents new ice cream hand crank machine 1851 Jacob Fussell starts 1st U.S. ice cream business Save tummyroom when visiting Mores Ice Cream in Middletown, MD ”
“ This place is amazing! I was so shocked to see we were the only ones here on a Friday night! Service is amazing, the place very clean, and had great luxury seating upstairs. I also love how the napkin holders have little quotes on them, and how music was constantly playing on the porch. I recommend coming here if your looking for a sweet treat! ”
“ It was my first time coming to the shop, friendly employees, good icecream licking flavors, and a very true sign of youll want more blew me away. Its cheaper than Baskin Robins for sure and my family and I really couldnt leave without one more cone. 1010 I recommend. ”
“ My wife and Daughter stopped for ice cream not knowing they were closed, a man let them in and my daughter got her ice cream, thank you for making my kids day!!! Your kindness didnt go unnoticed!!! ”
“ Im surprised I have not rated this place earlier, Ive been here on dozens of occasions. This is the place where I would recommend any ice cream enjoyer come, since the prices are amazing for what you get. At most times of the year, when its open, they actually sell the ice cream cheaper than South Mountain Creamerys Storefront which is where Mores gets their ice cream from, and its still just as fresh with many more options. The place is mainly staffed by the students of the high school, but they do a great job and are very kind to meet and greet every customer. This will always be a place I would come back to even if I moved away from Maryland. ”
“ Amazing staff and super friendly. 10 out of 10. We live around the corner and truly the best ice cream and experience me and my family have had!! ”